Page 1 of 2

AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Sun Apr 19, 2015 2:48 pm
by Arunion
AR2 A 343 007 (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

Welcome to the 343rd AR2 A contest: 007 Beneath

This is a repeatish of the seventh AR2 A league challenge, but please do not examine and/or copy any solutions from the original challenge. Because, where's the challenge in that?
Besides, Version 2.1.3 presently in use, means the same solution is not guaranteed to work.

Rules:
Cheapest solution wins.
All 3 dillos need to complete.
Prices changed

Submissions by PM

Good luck to all and have fun

New Players:
If you have never entered a competition before, please join in. We welcome and encourage new players. Don't be afraid to ask questions.

Naming convention is:
[DollarsRemaining]-[YourFourmName]-[SolutionName]

Example:
900-peterstock-MySolutionRocks

GMT Time link: http://wwp.greenwichmeantime.com/

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Sun Apr 19, 2015 6:52 pm
by mark_man
wow that was hard 666+ :twisted:

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 8:41 pm
by bythelee
I haven't got to try this yet, but doing it the light way, as dec10 would say it, will be massively difficult.

So, here's a potential spoiler:
Something I noticed when I first started competing, is that the pros could find ways to build solid plates that spat out on the "wrong" side.
In other words, a catcher could be made to shoot downwards, perhaps held by ropes, which saves an awful lot of trouble threading clever catchers through the hole.

I never discovered how they did it though. Something about zooming in very close, and repositioning the ends, and even whether you went left to right or right to left.
You just have to keep on trying, building and editing any way you can think of, until it works.
It's kinda like the Indian Rope Trick. But not. If you know what I mean. :D

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 10:16 pm
by mark_man
I have this level by the short and curlers now ,just doing my last tweak .Good luck everyone :)

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Fri Apr 24, 2015 9:24 pm
by decsystem10
bythelee wrote:I haven't got to try this yet, but doing it the light way, as dec10 would say it, will be massively difficult. :D


Well - that meant I had to try something !

I have 2 ideas. but the first has gone on forever, and I have to say I can't find time or fiddle-ability for the second.

So now, M'luds - a thing I haven't seen before you may all like to pass judgement on.
Because of the positioning of the portals, a low-dropping Dillo will trigger 'Game failed'.
However, all DIllos succeed in passing the portal.

Is that success or failure?

Meanwhile, by tweaking which owed more to red wine than logic I have a working (?) solution but its unbelievably sensitive so I have no intention of trying to improve it.
[and it's too low a score for markman's final twiddle)

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Fri Apr 24, 2015 10:54 pm
by mark_man
My tweak is possible because I have made cloth do what I have a plank doing now but after 3 hours of trying i have given up umtill the scores catch up .So please post your score so I can have some insentive x

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Sat Apr 25, 2015 3:37 pm
by mark_man
To answer your question on the fail thing ,yes its a fail in my opinion .because its possible to pass the level without failing .

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Sun Apr 26, 2015 12:11 pm
by mark_man
1991+

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Sun Apr 26, 2015 6:23 pm
by bythelee
Sorry I've been distracted all week.... haven't even had a chance to build a solution yet.

As for dec10's "fail", I remember a previous challenge that had this issue.
Of dillos passing so far out of the playing area that a "level failed" message appears.
On that occasion, a solution was valid if the dillos completed the level as intended. If the dillos all portalled away as expected, the solution was accepted. The build area was very small, so the dillos did not have to travel far to trigger the fail.

The game itself applies the failure before the successful completion, so it does not register the success. But for the purposes of the challenge, the limits at which dillos are deemed to have ventured "too far" are artificial, unpredictable, and unseen. That the dillos can still return to the portals to complete the level, highlights how arbitrary those limits are.
So personally, I feel that any solution that successfully portals the dillos away is a valid solution to our challenges.

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Sun Apr 26, 2015 9:33 pm
by Arunion
I think I agree with bythelee. If all the dillo's vanish, I'll consider it a win despite it "failing" according to the game. We do make our own rules here, and the level presents enough issues as it is :)

I'm also sorry because I've also been distracted lately. I have had a fair bit on my plate and my brain doesn't want to show me how to solve both this level or my issues irl... :P

So sorry mark_man but I don't have an insentive for you to get a better solution :lol:

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Tue Apr 28, 2015 2:53 pm
by bythelee
Finally hitting the challenge hard. And hard it is.... no solution yet, but I'm getting close.


As for the "level failed" validity, I'm seeing that warning come up when the dillos are barely into the lower half of the portal. It is thus possible to trigger the warning even when the dillos have never gone beyond the portal limits. I think it would be extremely harsh to disqualify any solution for triggering the "level failed" extremity warning in this particular challenge.

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Tue Apr 28, 2015 3:01 pm
by mark_man
Things were a bit stricter back in the day and it seems intentional to me ,but it is up to the op to decide and we have that decision :D .I will not need to alter my attempt eater way (spoiler)cheaper to do it the none fail way :oops: :twisted: .
Update score 2121+ :twisted:

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 10:18 am
by decsystem10
Ah! Just got back to this.
'Fail' is only a matter of interest,really - but nice to see the conversation.
I don't think my original quickie is going to threaten anybody's scores!
I'm afraid I'm not going to have time to do a proper one, although I do fancy my clockwork idea.

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 4:58 pm
by bythelee
OK, so I've got a solution.
But rope is rather pricey, isn't it? :oops:
at 12xx, it's not even close to threatening the 1991+ nor the 2121+ update scores.


Was there any comment in the original competition about "level failed" problems?

Re: AR2 A 343 007 Beneath (ends 2nd May 2015 @ 20h00 GMT)

PostPosted: Fri May 01, 2015 6:10 pm
by mark_man
2345+ Come on give me that reason to tweak :twisted: